Mockumentary, the term designated to a fictitious documentary, may sound like a humorous form of the medium but when it is given the horror treatment a mockumentary can completely transform a basic narrative into a curious source of fright as seen in writer and director Joel Anderson’s Australian horror, Lake Mungo. Dread and duplicity share the same body of water as one girl’s disappearance, the investigation that follows, and the everlasting effects of her death reach a uniquely haunting depth. Lake Mungo makes a notable impact as not only a well-conceived portrayal of polarizing family devastation, but as an elevated ghost story that is certain to be a captivating experience for all kinds of genre fans. Crafted in a sobering, dreamy tone, Lake Mungo explores the pain of loss through an applicable and appropriate medium met with stellar performances and a creeping, momentous feeling of dread that fills each scene.
Anderson’s underestimated gem of a film begins when “Alice drowns while swimming and her family begins experiencing inexplicable events in their home. The family hires a parapsychologist whose investigation unveils Alice’s secret double life and leads them all to Lake Mungo.” Anderson’s calm, but thrilling family horror film was distributed through Lionsgate and After Dark Films, following a widely successful release at South By Southwest in 2009 and the subsequent After Dark Horrorfest in 2010. Starring Talia Zucker (Motel Acacia), Martin Sharpe (Serving Joy), Rosie Traynor (Cut Snake), David Pledger (One Night Stand), and Steve Jodrell (City Homicide), Lake Mungo introduces a seemingly average case of murder mystery as viewers dip their toes into its fresh pond of plot and character development. However, just as it cautiously wades the waters of drama and doubt, Lake Mungo unexpectedly plunges into cold waves of shock and belief.
The story revolving around Alice’s disappearance may follow typical circumstances at first, but Lake Mungo dives deep into both the mysteries and realities of tragedy. Embracing the somber energy and cumulative tension of a missing innocent teenager, this mockumentary expands greatly on one family’s search for answers and the turmoil they face when the response is more than what they expected to receive. The film does well to field an informative commentary of a young woman’s complex adolescence and the severe complications her loved ones experience following her absence. What separates Lake Mungo from settling as a faux “true crime” documentary is the hint of supernatural elements that ultimately coat the initial intrigue in definitive mystery. Chilling reveals hang on deliberative theories while cold hard displays of imagery and a fluid progression through time contribute to Lake Mungo’s undeniably engaging content. Like the harsh display of the word ‘Missing’, Lake Mungo strikes observers quickly in the uncomfortable company of heavy and bewildering material.
Alice’s family members are all subjected to the afflictions of her disappearance, which is a terrifying reality in itself. The foundational events posit a controlled missing case on the surface. However Alice’s brother, Mathew, begins an alternative kind of investigation that results in shocking discovery after discovery proving that the mechanics at work are far from shallow happenings. Lake Mungo has this candid ability to draw viewers in, push them out, and pull them back in again. Before they have time to comprehend the nightmare that is unfolding, a new vehicle for authentic horror is introduced. Each of the players, and their respective performances and roles, create relatable tensions filled with applicable emotion. Like all missing person cases, Lake Mungo keeps the attention on Alice as the central character, but interestingly enough transforms that attention through a series of dark secrets, misguided manipulations, and an eerie atmosphere.
Documentaries, and therefore mockumentaries, intend to present subject matter worth analyzing. By breaking down the story at hand, the documentation piece of the process carefully feeds viewers information which makes for a unique journey compared to that of a narrative. Lake Mungo utilizes a mockumentary platform to lay out the details of Alice’s life and supposed drowning as well as the strange events that transpire in her family’s home. Its range of content in multiple mediums, true to documentary style form, makes for gut wrenching moments on top of scary, slinking sequences. Taking place around and within the Australian outback as well as throughout the suburbs of Arat, Anderson provides movement through his volatile settings. As the testimonies and commentaries are shared, our focus as viewers is brought to new places that the tragedy has reached. Each place, especially the Palmer home, contributes a true feeling of generic comfort which enhances the sentiment that is slowly submerged in fear. The lake itself is a mode for reflective nuance as The Palmer family and others reason and explore Alice’s death.
One of Lake Mungo’s greatest attributes is the use of testimonials and commentaries to drive its narrative. Poignant confessionals from the Palmers and Alice’s friends and neighbors illustrate the film with raw emotion while found footage inclusions provoke harrowing, dreadful situations. The use of multiple video types of video recordings not only provide the film with a variety of mediums, as documentaries do, but also contributes to the variation of perspective. All work in a fluid formation to come together and build on a successful mockumentary medium that is sure to hit first-time viewers. There is a different kind of crime story being told here, one that does not shy away from the unusual nor the unexplainable. At the same time, there is also a different kind of psychological horror being presented with a true ghost story unfolding in a very authentic, original manner. Anderson’s ability to address the timeline, maintain cinematic integrity, and manipulate the viewer mentally and visually are all major feats of quality filmmaking. Lake Mungo is a brilliant exercise in formatting genuine domestic horror interspersed by daunting paranormal outfits.
18 years before the loss of Alice Palmer, the death of another young woman broke her sleepy town of Twin Peaks into pieces setting new ground for loss and grief in entertainment. Like Laura Palmer, Alice’s untimely death drenches her local surroundings in mourning. Anderson’s simple narrative in heartbreak and trauma leaves the secondary characters of Lake Mungo to sort through the wreckage of a bleak unknown. Consequence is key to developing the incidents that take place and the speculations behind some of the more sinister circumstances. Like all constructive documentaries, Lake Mungo allows viewers enough room to ask questions, form opinions, and even has those necessary cracks for uncertainty to slowly drip through. The pain is tangible and oddly surreal given the film’s structure. Long shots, hyper-focused imagery, and committed contemplation mirror the emotional catharsis that accompanies death. The effect sits comfortably in a heavy atmosphere diluted by paranormal belief which subsequently, and in compliment, alters the intensity of Lake Mungo’s drama.
The depth of death’s effect knows no bounds as the strange aftermath infiltrates the Palmers’ residence. Generational divides, criminal suspicions, and even suburban scandal all play a part in Lake Mungo’s comprehensive tragedy. On the other hand, questionable spectres, a discernible presence, and uncanny overtones cast a moving shadow veiled with significance. As Anderson joins the two modes of content in a controlled and ominous fashion, illustrated further by a veritable screenplay, Lake Mungo sets itself apart from found footage dozens and haunted house hundreds. All in all, despite the grim instances of spiritual horror, Lake Mungo is an ambitious look at grief and perseverance. The struggle to deal with a lost loved one’s presence permeates the home and spaces of their existence like a ghost. This docufiction spins the idea into swift genre material that applies considerable taste and careful reflection in its meaning. Memory serves as both Lake Mungo’s interestingly toxic factor as well as the ultimate element of strength and resolution.
“Lake Mungo is a brilliant exercise in formatting genuine domestic horror interspersed by daunting paranormal outfits.“
Personally, I really love a good film that leaves you with something to chew on. I chose not to delve into the details of Lake Mungo as it is one best enjoyed blindly. My first viewing was memorable as I had no idea what to expect from the start and I truly underestimated the lasting effect it would have. Given its limited release back in 2009 and its After Dark Horrorfest branding, I was a little skeptical. By the time I hit the halfway point, I had already found myself immersed in every sequence. It is highly recommended for anyone who thinks that they have seen it all and is more than a suggested viewing for those who enjoy the crafty oeuvre of horror mockumentaries. Lake Mungo is a collective piece of evocative genre filmmaking that play tricks with on viewers throughout with relentless trust. As the credits rolled, revealing more on top of an already tremendous pool of haunting content, I realized that Lake Mungo was special. Something about it, probably the many high points, continue to resonate within me like the faint print of a long lost, but not forgotten, ghost.
Lake Mungo is currently streaming on Tubi.
Are you a fan of Lake Mungo? What do you think about this mysterious horror mockumentary? Did you see all the twists coming? Let us know your thoughts over on Twitter, Reddit, or in the Horror Movie Fiend Club on Facebook!