The Cell Movie 2000 Jennifer Lopez
New Line Cinema

10 Great Horror Movies That Are Way Better Than Their Low Rotten Tomatoes Scores

Jennifer'S Body 2009
20Th Century Studios

5. Jennifer’s Body (2009) – Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 46%

Jennifer’s Body, starring Megan Fox as Jennifer and Amanda Seyfried as Needy, flips the script on the typical high school horror narrative, delivering a feminist critique wrapped in a succubus story. Its witty dialogue and commentary on friendship, power, and desire have garnered a cult following, proving that critics don’t always get the last laugh. This film bites back with humor and horror, making it a must-watch for those looking to sink their teeth into something with style.. and substance.

Where to Watch:
Final Destination 2000
New Line Cinema

4. Final Destination (2000) – Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 36%

Final Destination introduces us to Alex (Devon Sawa), who, after having a premonition of a deadly plane crash, escapes his fated demise along with a few others. What follows is a relentless chase by death itself, seeking to correct the cosmic balance. The film’s inventive death scenes and the constant tension of escaping the inescapable grip of fate have thrilled audiences, despite what the critics say. It’s a rollercoaster that proves avoiding death is as futile as trying to silence a scream in a nightmare.

Where to Watch:
The Strangers 2008

3. The Strangers (2008) – Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 49%

With a simple premise of a home invasion by masked assailants, The Strangers starring Liv Tyler as Kristen and Scott Speedman as James, turns an ordinary night into an unending ordeal of terror. Its mastery lies in its minimalism, proving that real horror often comes not from ghouls, but from the unknown. Critics may have been divided, but for those who appreciate a slow-burn terror that builds to a heart-pounding climax, this film delivers.

Where to Watch:


nightmare on film street horror movie tshirts
nightmare on film street horror movie tshirts
Saw 2004 Saw Franchise Explained Saw Movie Guide Explained

2. Saw (2004) – Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 50%

Saw, the film that launched a franchise and defined ‘torture porn,’ presents a grim game of survival between two men at the mercy of the Jigsaw killer (Tobin Bell). While it might have been too gruesome for some critics, its ingenious plot twists and moral dilemmas have ensnared a legion of fans. This gritty, psychological thriller invites viewers to question their own values and survival instincts, making it an unforgettable entry in the horror genre.

Where to Watch:
Freddy Vs Jason
New Line Cinema

1. Freddy vs. Jason (2003) – Rotten Tomatoes Rating: 42%

When two titans of terror, Freddy (Robert Englund) and Jason (Ken Kirzinger), clash, it’s not just a battle—it’s a spectacle. Freddy vs. Jason merges the worlds of Nightmare on Elm Street and Friday the 13th, offering fans a long-awaited showdown. While it might not be high art, this film delivers on its promise of a bloody, entertaining brawl. It’s a fan service fiesta that knows exactly what it is and revels in it, making it the ultimate guilty pleasure for horror junkies.

Where to Watch:

In the realm of horror, a Rotten Tomatoes score is just a number that can’t capture the heart-pounding, adrenaline-pumping, and sometimes, gleefully absurd experiences these films offer. So next time you’re browsing for a horror movie, remember that “rotten” might just mean ripe for discovery. Whether you’re in it for the scares, the laughs, or the sheer thrill of the chase, these films prove that there’s more to horror than meets the eye—or the critic’s pen.

Can you name more killer horror flicks that got the Rotten rating? Let us know over in the Nightmare on Film Street Community on Discord!

nightmare on film street best horror movie podcast background mobile
nightmare on film street best horror movie podcast background