5. Saint (2010)
On the fifth day of Christmas, my true scare gave to me: Saint, a Dutch masterstroke that repackages a venerated yuletide legend into the nightmare before Christmas. Delving into the mythos of Saint Nicholas, this horror-fantasy hybrid delivers a feast of chills and thrills—complete with a bishop’s miter dripping with something much more sinister than frankincense.
Where to Watch:
4. Rare Exports: A Christmas Tale (2010)
At the fourth spot lies a tale brimming with chilling Scandinavian lore, Rare Exports: A Christmas Tale. It peels back the cheerful veneer of holiday myths to expose something ancient, something primeval, and decidedly not suitable for the kiddies. A slow-burn cinematic advent calendar of foreboding, this film crafts tension as meticulously as a woodcarver whittles away at his eerie creations.
Where to Watch:
3. Christmas Evil (1980)
Cloaked in the guise of holiday cheer, Christmas Evil presents a psychological journey into a disturbed mind with a deeply ingrained Santa fixation. It’s a vintage piece of holiday horror that casts a long shadow, exploring the blurred lines between good intentions and grisly outcomes, all wrapped up with a bow of macabre melancholy.
Where to Watch:
2. Deadly Games (Dial Code Santa Claus) (1989)
Just one nightmare before the top, Deadly Games is a French foray into festive fear that may have slipped under many radars. In this heart-pounding bout of hide-and-seek, a young boy’s ingenuity is pitted against a sinister figure whose Santa suit hides a hunter’s heart. A frenetic, fantastical surge of adrenaline, the film stands as a precursor to home invasion thrillers that would come in its wake.
Where to Watch:
1. Silent Night, Deadly Night (1984)
Perched at the peak of our list like a star atop a particularly petrifying Christmas tree, Silent Night, Deadly Night remains the definitive depiction of the evil Santa. Despite—or likely because of—its controversial subject matter, it has earned a revered place in the halls of holiday horror. The film reminds us with every shadow-laden, snowy scene that sometimes the greatest horrors are wrapped in the most familiar packaging.
Where to Watch:
With this extensive list of evil Santas, we invite you to bask in the horrific holiday spirit that runs as red as Rudolph’s nose. These tales of misdeeds, malice, and macabre merry-making ensure that even the most hardened horror fans will find a new way to celebrate—or rather, commiserate—the festive season. So gather your courage, pour a sinister glass of nog, and brace yourself for a tour through the chilling possibilities that await when Santa sheds his merry mantle in favor of malevolence. It’s sure to be a holiday viewing experience you’ll never forget, providing spine-tingling terror in the name of old Saint Nick.
Who’s your favorite Bad Santa of horror? Let us know over in the Nightmare on Film Street Discord!
