Session 9 | Focus Features

The 10 Scariest Horror Movies You’ve Never Heard Of

Are you a horror movie enthusiast in search of the scariest horror hidden gems that will truly terrify you? Look no further! This listicle will introduce you to ten lesser-known horror films that are guaranteed to send shivers down your spine. These under-the-radar movies may not have received mainstream attention, but they offer unique plot twists, innovative scares, and an unsettling atmosphere that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

Here are The 10 Scariest Horror Movies You’ve Never Heard Of.


Session 9 Movie

Session 9 (2001)

“A group of asbestos removal workers begins experiencing supernatural occurrences while working at an abandoned mental asylum. As tensions rise and their sanity unravels, they discover the dark secrets that haunt the building.”

Why it’s worth watching: Session 9 is a psychological horror masterpiece that relies on atmosphere and slow-burning tension. With stellar performances and a haunting setting, it will leave you questioning your own sanity.



Lake Mungo Featured

Lake Mungo (2008)

“After a teenage girl drowns in a local dam, her family begins experiencing paranormal phenomena. Through a mix of documentary-style interviews, found footage, and eerie imagery, the film explores grief, loss, and the presence of the supernatural.”

Why it’s worth watching: Lake Mungo is a unique and deeply unsettling film that takes a fresh approach to the found footage genre. It delves into the psychological and emotional aftermath of a tragedy while delivering unexpected twists till the very end.



Absentia 2011

 Absentia (2011)

“Tricia’s husband has been missing for seven years, and she is ready to declare him dead in absentia. However, as she begins to move on with her life, unsettling occurrences and a mysterious tunnel near her home suggest that her husband’s disappearance may be connected to something much darker.”

Why it’s worth watching: Absentia is a low-budget horror film that excels in building an atmosphere of dread and psychological unease. It explores themes of grief, loss, and the thin line between reality and the supernatural.




nightmare on film street horror movie tshirts
nightmare on film street horror movie tshirts
Noroi The Curse

Noroi: The Curse (2005)

“A documentary filmmaker investigates a series of strange and supernatural events, leading him to uncover a terrifying ancient curse. Through found footage, interviews, and a creeping sense of dread, the film builds a web of chilling mystery.”

Why it’s worth watching: Noroi: The Curse is a Japanese found-footage film that excels in building an atmosphere of escalating dread. It slowly pulls you into its chilling narrative, leaving you with a lingering sense of unease.



Pontypool Brue Mcdonald Stephen Mchattie

Pontypool (2008)

“A radio DJ and his crew find themselves trapped inside their station as a mysterious virus spreads, causing people to turn into violent and incoherent beings. The film explores the power of language and communication as the characters fight to survive.”

Why it’s worth watching: Pontypool is a unique and thought-provoking horror film that reinvents the zombie genre. It relies on suspense, clever dialogue, and a sense of confinement to create a chilling and intellectually stimulating experience.



Starry Eyes 4

Starry Eyes (2014)

“A young actress desperate for fame and success becomes entangled in a sinister Hollywood cult. As she sacrifices her identity and sanity, she realizes the horrific price she must pay for her dreams.”

Why it’s worth watching: Starry Eyes is a disturbing and atmospheric horror film that explores the dark underbelly of the entertainment industry. It combines body horror elements with a psychological narrative, offering a thought-provoking and unsettling viewing experience.


The Taking Of Deborah Logan
Millennium Entertainment


The Taking of Deborah Logan (2014)

A documentary crew follows an elderly woman with Alzheimer’s disease, only to uncover a terrifying supernatural presence that possesses her. As the line between reality and nightmare blurs, the filmmakers must confront the ancient evil.

Why it’s worth watching: The Taking of Deborah Logan is a found footage horror film that deftly combines psychological horror with supernatural elements. It features a standout performance by Jill Larson as the titular character and delivers unexpected twists that will leave you unnerved.



The Autopsy Of Jane Doe 2016
Ifc Films

The Autopsy of Jane Doe (2016)

“A father-and-son team of coroners conducts an autopsy on an unidentified woman, only to discover increasingly bizarre and terrifying secrets as they delve deeper into her body. As night falls, they must race against time to uncover the truth.”

Why it’s worth watching: The Autopsy of Jane Doe is a suspenseful and expertly crafted horror film that takes place in a confined and chilling space; a morgue. With a gripping storyline and standout performances, it will keep you guessing until the chilling finale.



A Dark Song 2016
Ifc Films

A Dark Song (2016)

“A grieving mother and an occultist lock themselves in an isolated house to perform a dangerous ritual that will allow them to communicate with her deceased son. As their sanity is tested, they realize the true nature of the forces they have invoked.”

Why it’s worth watching: A Dark Song is a slow-burning and atmospheric horror film that explores grief, loss, and the lengths people will go to find closure. It combines supernatural elements with a character-driven narrative, resulting in a haunting and emotionally resonant experience.



The Wailing 2016
20Th Century Studios

The Wailing (2016)

“A small Korean village is plagued by a mysterious illness and a series of gruesome murders. A bumbling police officer must uncover the truth behind these horrific events, leading him on a journey that blurs the line between good and evil.”

Why it’s worth watching: The Wailing is a masterfully crafted horror film that combines elements of supernatural horror, psychological thriller, and police procedural. It delves into themes of guilt, paranoia, and the consequences of unchecked evil, leaving you guessing until the shocking climax.


If you’re seeking a fresh dose of terror, these lesser-known scariest horror films are the perfect choice. From psychological horrors to supernatural nightmares, they offer innovative scares, unexpected plot twists, and a chilling atmosphere that will leave a lasting impression. So, dim the lights, brace yourself, and discover these hidden gems that are guaranteed to send shivers down your spine!

Have more underrated scariest horror movie suggestions? Tweet at us, or better yet, start a conversation in the Nightmare on Film Street Discord!


nightmare on film street best horror movie podcast background mobile
nightmare on film street best horror movie podcast background